That was the sticky question my four-year-old asked me yesterday and my answer started waterworks that would go on for two hours.
It began innocently enough. We were having dinner which included pasta in a tomato sauce with ground beef. We began talking about the origin of the pasta and how it was made, then the origin of the tomato sauce and how it was made, and then we got to the beef. Uh-oh.
Well, Benjamin, my tentative answer was,
meat comes from cows.No, it doesn't, Mommy, he said.
Milk comes from cows.Well, yes, milk comes from cows and so does meat, I said.
How? he asked.
Uh, well, the meat, uh, sort of is, uh, the cow, I said.
Silence.
Do you mean they kill the cow? he asked.
Yes, I mumbled, and then said brightly and loudly,
Hey, Benjamin, why don't we make cookies after dinner?Bbbbbbbut, I like cows! I don't want people to kill them! he said, bursting into tears.
Oh boy. How do I get out of this one, I thought.
Do they use a knife? he asked.
A knife is sharp and it will hurt them. I love cows!He then proceeded to refuse to eat his dinner and threw himself on the sofa in tears. He asked me if we could write a letter to the "bad guys" to tell them that it's not nice to kill cows.
He also asked me to buy only the meat that the store makes, not the meat that comes from cows. I said okay [LIE]. I was desperate to stop him from crying and to be honest, I just didn't know what to do! Suggestions?